Liner locks - yea or nay?

topic posted Tue, April 25, 2006 - 9:24 AM by  Genghis "Doh!"
I'm curious what you all think about liner locks as a knife locking mechanism. I've encountered comments from designers saying they went to liner locks because they're the best option and comments from people who think they're a waste. Or is the quality of the knife the best indicator of whether the liner lock is solid?

Thanks, G
  • Re: Liner locks - yea or nay?

    Tue, April 25, 2006 - 10:38 AM
    I prefer a frame lock any day of the week, but unless its a blade that requires a lot of torque or striking from wierd angles (like say a karambit) I'd trust a nice solid titanium liner.

    Most of my regular folders are liner locks and, although admittedly I very rarely do anything with them I would consider *hard* use, I've never had one fail.
  • Re: Liner locks - yea or nay?

    Tue, April 25, 2006 - 4:52 PM
    i carry one of decent quality at all times; i also cary a fixed blade at all times. i think you hit it correctly when you asked about quality being an indicator of whether a liner lock was solid--my answer to that question is gotta do it sorry WELL DUH any decent knife of any configuration will be just what it is a fairly decent blade, all depends on what your using them for. don't hammer on the f....er what i have is a little 3 inch blade light weight cheap gerber twenty bucks i love it use it for all general use nice toothpick even did a deer with it (woman in front hit it, i finished it and took it home) it's $20 i'll never miss.
    • Re: Liner locks - yea or nay?

      Fri, April 28, 2006 - 7:03 PM
      Liner lock, frame lock, or axis lock, as I can open and close the knife easily with either hand singled handedly. Lockbacks are too slow.
      • Unsu...
         

        Re: Liner locks - yea or nay?

        Fri, April 28, 2006 - 8:20 PM
        Liner locks are fine. Use the knife as intended and you'll have no problems.

        EVAN-
        I've needed to OPEN a knife in a hurry, but I can't say that I've ever need to CLOSE one quickly. Lockback are as strong as any of the others listed and nearly as easy to close, just slower. YMMV.

        todd

Recent topics in "Knives & Blades"